Hundreds of cruise ships confounded the news media this week by NOT sinking, highlighting a growing trend in the cruise industry of producing vessels that are safe, secure and, above all, fun to travel on.
OK, I’m being a touch frivolous with a serious issue, but the general public could be forgiven recently in light of the media’s rush to ‘celebrate’ the 100-year-old tragedy of the Titanic for thinking cruising has somehow become an inherently dangerous holiday choice.
Sadly, though, TV programmes like this week’s ‘Why Ships Sink’ on Channel 4 paint a massively distorted picture of reality and it is worth highlighting the facts rather than the fiction:
OK, I’m being a touch frivolous with a serious issue, but the general public could be forgiven recently in light of the media’s rush to ‘celebrate’ the 100-year-old tragedy of the Titanic for thinking cruising has somehow become an inherently dangerous holiday choice.
Sadly, though, TV programmes like this week’s ‘Why Ships Sink’ on Channel 4 paint a massively distorted picture of reality and it is worth highlighting the facts rather than the fiction:
- Each week, some 300 ships set sail worldwide, carrying roughly 310,000 passengers.
- More than 16 million people took a cruise in 2011. No ships sank.
- The only modern ship to sink in the past 10 years is Costa Concordia – due to a calamitous error by her captain, not a safety oversight.
- From 1997-2010, there were 380 plane crashes worldwide, resulting in almost 6,000 deaths.
I’m not pointing fingers at the airline industry here. Everyone has accidents and human error is a part of everyday life. In fact, for the mutli-millions of people carried every year, the safety record of the airline business is remarkable. But it is still several points worse than the cruise industry.
That’s why I feel compelled to offer some balance and perspective to the current debate. Or, more simply, what Channel 4 peddled as a 'documentary' was just more scurrilous garbage posing as 'news' coverage.
The Titanic WAS 100 years ago, folks, and a lot of lessons have been learned since then. Cruise ships are inherently safe, and, while nobody is saying they are foolproof (NB: for the record, no-one at White Star Line or Harland and Wolff shipyard EVER said their ship was 'unsinkable'), they are certainly not the death-traps that Channel 4 and others would have you believe.
Can they be safer? Of course, and one-off incidents like Concordia will ensure that is the case. But for supposed news media to suggest otherwise is just muck-raking (or ambulance-chasing) of the worst kind.
PS: to answer the question, Why Ships Don't Sink: because they are incredibly well-engineered by high-tech modern designers using design processes and state-of-the-art computer programmes that take advantage of marine architecture progress over the last 50 years. If they were really putting out shoddy work, we'd have known about it years ago.
No comments:
Post a Comment